How to Get More Reviews (The Right Way): A Small Business Playbook

Running a small business? Let’s talk about the power of online reviews. With the right approach, user-generated content (UGC) can boost your reputation and drive profitability. Today, we’ll explore how to make reviews work for you without falling into any traps. Here’s what we’ll cover:

• How not to get reviews
• How to earn more, fresher, and keyword-rich reviews
• Scaling reputation management for growing businesses

Before we dive in, here’s a key principle:

You’ll get more reviews if you ask for them.

It sounds simple, but many small businesses miss this step. Let’s change that by building an effective strategy for review acquisition.

How Not to Get Reviews

Reviews are critical for influencing customer decisions and improving your online visibility. However, some businesses try to manipulate the system, which can lead to penalties or even legal trouble. Here’s what not to do:

• Don’t offer incentives like discounts or freebies in exchange for reviews.
• Never write fake reviews or have someone else do it for you.
• Avoid asking friends, family, or employees to leave reviews.
• Don’t write negative reviews about competitors.
• Stay away from review gating—only inviting happy customers to leave feedback while ignoring the dissatisfied ones.
• Never outsource unethical practices to marketers or agencies.
• Do not review your own business.

Stick to honest, customer-driven feedback. Google’s Prohibited and Restricted Content guidelines offer more detail on what’s acceptable. Now, let’s look at how to earn reviews ethically.

How to Earn Effective Reviews

Here are 18 strategies to kickstart your review acquisition process:

1. Collect Customer Contact Info
   Gather emails and phone numbers at the point of sale or service. Using both email and SMS for review requests can increase responses.
2. Make Review Links Accessible
   Use tools to generate direct links to your Google Business Profile (GBP), making it easy for customers to leave reviews.
3. Provide Simple Instructions
   If your audience isn’t tech-savvy, include step-by-step instructions in your request.
4. Request Detailed Feedback
   Encourage customers to share specifics. This can lead to longer, keyword-rich reviews.
5. Ask Verbally
   If you can’t collect emails or numbers, simply ask for reviews in person during service.
6. Use Print Materials
   Add review requests to menus, receipts, flyers, or even store signage.
7. Leverage Your Website
   Place review requests on your site’s testimonial pages, product/service pages, or contact forms.
8. Utilize Digital Media
   Add review links to email newsletters and digital receipts.
9. Make Specific Requests
   Launching a new product? Ask for reviews about that item to boost visibility in search results.
10. Experiment with Timing
    Research shows review requests made 9–14 days after a transaction often receive better responses than immediate requests. Find the timing that works best for your business.
11. Respond to Reviews
    Show you value customer feedback by responding to all reviews, old and new.
12. Diversify Review Platforms
    Encourage reviews on multiple platforms, such as Yelp or industry-specific sites, to reach a broader audience.
13. Encourage First-Party Reviews
    Collect reviews on your own site in addition to third-party platforms.
14. Tap Into Influencers
    Seek reviews from industry bloggers, podcasters, and influencers who can amplify your brand’s reach.
15. Address Language Preferences
    Serve a multilingual community? Request reviews in languages your customers are most comfortable with.
16. Deliver Exceptional Experiences
    Positive experiences lead to positive reviews. If reviews are scarce, evaluate your customer service.
17. Support Franchisees
    For franchise owners, ensure every location has the tools and guidelines to manage reviews effectively.
18. Monitor Your Reviews
    Keep an eye on your profiles to address any issues, such as disappearing reviews or technical problems.

Scaling Reputation Management

Managing reviews can be time-consuming, especially as your business grows. For sole proprietors, manually handling reviews might work initially, but it becomes challenging as review volume increases.

For larger businesses, particularly those with multiple locations, investing in reputation management software is a smart move. These tools streamline the process of requesting, tracking, and responding to reviews, helping you stay organized and responsive.

Final Thoughts

The key takeaway? You’ll get more reviews by simply asking for them, but there’s a right way to do it. Stick to ethical practices, leverage technology, and make review management a priority. When done right, online reviews are a powerful tool that can elevate your small business, boosting visibility, credibility, and revenue.

FAQ’s

1. Why are online reviews important for my small business?
Online reviews influence potential customers, improve your local search rankings, and build trust. They can directly impact your revenue by helping new customers decide to do business with you.

2. How can I ask for reviews without breaking any rules?
Ask customers directly via email, SMS, or in person, but never offer incentives. Make it easy by providing direct links to your review profiles and clear instructions.

3. What are some examples of unethical review practices?
Offering incentives for reviews, writing fake reviews, review gating (only asking happy customers), and leaving negative reviews for competitors are all unethical and against Google’s guidelines.

4. How soon after a transaction should I ask for a review?
Studies suggest waiting 9–14 days after a transaction may yield the best response rates. However, timing can vary depending on your industry, so experiment to find what works best for your business.

5. Should I respond to all reviews?
Yes! Responding to reviews—both positive and negative—shows that you value customer feedback. It also helps build trust and demonstrates your commitment to customer service.

6. Can I manage reviews across multiple platforms?
Yes, and you should. Encourage reviews on Google, Yelp, and industry-specific platforms. Use reputation management software to help streamline this process if you’re managing multiple locations or service areas.

7. What if I get a negative review?
Respond promptly and professionally. Acknowledge the customer’s experience, offer a resolution, and show that you care about improving. Never ignore or argue with negative feedback.

8. How do I know if my review management strategy is working?
Track key metrics like review volume, average star rating, and changes in local search rankings. Regularly monitor customer feedback to ensure continuous improvement.

---

Need Help Improving Your Website?

At SEO Windy City, we offer one-time SEO projects to audit and tune up your website, as well as monthly SEO management services including ongoing auditing, technical fixes, content development, consulting, and reporting. Click here to request a quote for SEO services.